Anyone who’s ever owned a business has wished there were a magical app to swipe away all that business debt. Unfortunately, that’s not how it works.
There are two tactics, restructuring and consolidation, that can make a mountain of debt easier to climb. Both have the objective of making a bunch of debt more manageable, but the way you get there is different. Many people confuse the two terms, so let’s break them down here.
Anything related to running a business involves a myriad of nuances and variables. This topic is no exception. You should always keep in mind the fact that your unique situation may differ significantly from anyone else. To best handle it, get an in-house CFO or CFO consultant and weigh your decision together with their advice.
Here, we’ll define both of these terms, and then do a bit of compare-and-contrast. Then we’ll help you figure out which one is best for you and your small business.
Debt Restructuring
In a debt restructuring the debtor (you) and the creditor (the lender) agree to how much of the debt is repaid. No new contract is signed, but the old one’s modified. Part of the debt might be forgiven. Repayment is usually done as a percentage of the total owed, e.g. 60%. There’s some give, and some take. The success of the deal hinges on what the company can pay and what the creditor’s willing to forgive.
It’s a last-ditch effort to save a failing company, often pursued by companies in a big financial hole. Why would a creditor ever agree to it? Getting something now is likely more than a creditor would receive later from a failing business. And if the company survives, the creditor doesn’t have to go through the arduous and expensive bankruptcy process.
Consolidating Several, Smaller Loans into a Single Loan
Debt consolidation is one form of debt refinancing. It’s for less dire financial situations. It’s simply the process of consolidating several, smaller loans into a single loan. It’s different than restructuring because in restructuring a contract gets renegotiated; but in consolidation, a few smaller loans get combined into one big loan.
That lump of smaller loans is converted into one loan at a lower interest rate. The money you were paying for interest is freed up, and can go toward paying off your balance. After the consolidation, you can choose between smaller monthly payments, or a faster payoff. This depends on your goals and cashflow.
In a debt consolidation, a new contract is signed. New terms are agreed upon. In order to complete the process, the borrower has to submit the same documents it used to apply for the original loans. This means submitting financials, tax returns, sales projections, etc. Lenders for consolidations include banks, credit unions, alternative lenders, and even governmental programs such as the Small Business Administration. Usually, the borrower’s goal is better cash flow and more attainable repayment.
Which Do You Go for, Restructuring or Consolidation
Now we’ll compare-and-contrast the two, then you can decide which one should suit you.
The two overlap because both make debt more manageable. They differ because in a restructuring, an existing contract is modified and a percentage of the debt is forgiven. In a consolidation, a new, lower-rate loan is borrowed.
So, which do you go for, restructuring or consolidation? Sometimes, that’s not an easy answer.
Well, that depends. What type of debt? How much? It depends on how big your company is, how much money you make (or don’t make) and what industry you’re in. It’s difficult to say without your own CFO evaluating your company and figuring out the options. Your CFO will know the whole picture of your company’s financial well-being and know what’s the best option for your company. Having a CFO’s professional opinion on this is paramount.
One catch: whichever you choose, lenders and creditors have the final say. Lenders and creditors set their own underwriting guidelines for restructuring and consolidation, and may reject you based on their own requirements. Your creditors may refuse to restructure if you’re not in dire enough financial shape. Frankly, though, if you aren’t in that type of trouble, a restructuring probably isn’t the best option for you. Lenders offering consolidation may decline if the company is too young or has a low credit score. Even if your credit’s good, the total amount you owe may be too big to consolidate.
If you’re in a desperate situation, trust your CFO to strategize your way through the crisis. If you don’t have a CFO, that’s okay. You can hire a fractional CFO. A fractional CFO is also referred to as a CFO consultant.
Next, figure out your goals, then go discuss it with your finance team and your creditors. But if you’re losing money, restructuring and consolidation is a band-aid; it buys you time. Without a long-term, sound business strategy the restructure or consolidation only delays your company’s failure. It takes a sound long-term business strategy to generate revenue and to keep it coming. You don’t get there by restructuring or consolidating debt. If you don’t know how to get there, bring in a financial professional such as a CFO or consultant.