A troubled company often assumes that bankruptcy, whether a Chapter 11 reorganization or a Chapter 7 liquidation, is the only alternative available to the company. But this is not necessarily true. Bankruptcy offers distinct advantages for certain troubled companies, but it may not be the right choice for your company. Bankruptcy is time consuming. A bankruptcy proceeding can be expensive and severely affect the parties’ rights, and therefore a company ought to consider all available alternatives before filing a bankruptcy petition.
Each of these options has its pros and cons. Non-bankruptcy solutions may offer distinct advantages over bankruptcy proceedings.
Four Other Methods
You ought to at least consider four other methods: receiverships, assignment for the benefit of creditors, Article 9 sales, and out-of-court workouts.
In a receivership, a court officer, the receiver, is appointed to manage or wind up a troubled company. The receiver answers to a judge. The receiver is also custodian for any property that is the subject of the receivership, and acts as a fiduciary for those who have an interest in that property. A receivership is usually commenced in state court where a secured creditor fears the debtor may be dissipating the assets in which that creditor has a security interest, because a receiver is empowered to protect and preserve all assets (as well as avoid waste).
In an assignment for the benefit of creditors, the debtor turns over its business and assets to a trustee, and the trust agreement directs the trustee to reduce the assets to money for the purpose of paying the assignor’s creditors. The process shares some advantages of both Chapter 7 and a section 363 sale. It is usually less time-consuming than bankruptcy, which is to say it can provide a quicker way to realize on a business’s assets. Another benefit of an assignment for the benefit of creditors (ABC) is that the creditors can participate in the liquidation plan, and the plan can be formulated by the company and the company’s creditors. An assignment for the benefit of creditors works much like a receivership, in that it employs a neutral third party to administer the company’s finances, property and other assets, but it does not require court appointment or supervision. But it will not stop creditors from filing lawsuits against the company.
The laws governing ABCs vary from state to state, and a few states do not recognize this process at all. Some states regulate assignment by statute; others handle it through common law. After the assignment, an assignee can either liquidate assets piecemeal or as an entire business. An assignee must act as a fiduciary for all creditors, maximizing value so that the creditors recover as much as possible.
Under U.C.C. Article 9, a secured creditor can repossess collateral. Following repossession, the creditor can either sell the collateral or keep it for itself to satisfy the debt. Most friendly negotiations occur with the debtor’s consent, but consent is not a requirement for the creditor to take this step. Section 9-610 of the U.C.C. allows a creditor in possession to sell collateral by public or private sale. Debtors may be better off cooperating with this process, which might allow them to negotiate a more favorable outcome (e.g. release of personal guarantees).
A Consensual Agreement Between Your Company and Creditors
Your company may benefit from a workout if creditors are willing to come to the bargaining table (they are not always). All the parties to the transaction may be better served if you can negotiate and complete a deal without the need for a court order, and this may prove far cheaper and more efficient than a formal bankruptcy proceeding. In a workout, the goal is to come up with a viable restructured repayment plan. That new payment plan is supposed to fit within your business’s cash flow.
How your workout takes shape depends on how distressed your business is, and the capital structure in place. Your company can consider different options, such as cutting the principal, extending maturity, or a combination of both. In a composition agreement, several creditors each accept a set amount, possibly deferred, as full payment for the debt they are owed. An exchange offer has similarities to a composition agreement. But instead of presenting a deal to all the creditors, this approach targets a specific class or particular group of creditors, such as lenders or bondholders.
A composition agreement or an exchange offer avoids the time, expense and publicity of bankruptcy. But you should remember the cons. Holdout creditors that refuse to consent to a workout agreement are not bound by it. A workout lacks the automatic stay of bankruptcy, and an out-of-court agreement does not enable the company to reject executory contracts.