When a borrower falls behind on its obligations under a credit line or a promissory note, the bank will sometimes pitch a forbearance agreement framed as a favor, a way to give the borrower more time to perform.
A forbearance agreement can give a distressed borrower breathing room to refinance or improve its situation. But it normally strengthens the bank’s hand while the borrower catches its breath.
It comes after the borrower’s default, when the lender already has its right to take collateral and sue for any deficiency. Forbearance details will vary by state law and by loan type. The agreement typically calls for several concessions by the borrower in exchange for an agreement by the lender to forbear, to hold off collection and enforcement while it remains in effect.
A forbearance agreement, no matter how small or routine, costs the borrower and any other signer something significant in exchange for time. The borrower and guarantors must understand everything to be given up and every change imposed by the forbearance agreement before signing it.
Most forbearance agreements will contain a lot of detail. Three big issues will govern how the forbearance process plays out.
Release Any Claim They Have Against the Lender
The first is exactly what the borrower is giving up in exchange for the time it’s buying.
In exchange for the lender’s promise to forbear, to hold back on exercising its rights under the loan documents, the borrower and other debtors normally will need to release any claim they have against the lender. If the bank has failed to live up to its side of the bargain, the forbearance release can cut that off, no matter what the lender’s wrongdoing may be.
The most generous reading of a waiver is to see it as a way for the parties to move beyond old issues. But a waiver at the start of a workout or restructuring comes with a tradeoff that may leave a big gap in the borrower’s defenses should the workout fail. One area is conduct on the part of the bank that may be improper or outright illegal. That all disappears under a waiver.
One exception may survive, but it is narrow. Even with a waiver, the borrower can bring claims that arise after the signing of the forbearance. A bank aware of claims the borrower may be able to press against it may try to use the waiver to reduce that risk. When making a decision that will take away claims against the other side, claims of any size or potential value, the borrower and guarantors need to count the cost and think through how much to give up.
Collateral or Cash
Forbearance agreements typically demand more from the borrower in collateral or cash. Whether you’re holding the pen as borrower or guarantor, it’s critical to understand every asset and dollar that is put at risk with a forbearance agreement. It may be that the bank’s reach includes assets that can’t be touched in any other way.
Say a business owner personally guaranteed the loan and is asked to sign off on the lender’s demand to add a lien on the owner’s home as additional collateral. Depending on where they live, it can make a big difference. For instance, in Missouri, that personal liability will not attach to the family home when it is owned jointly in both spouses’ names unless they both sign.
Owners and spouses need to think carefully about pledging their home for a company’s debt. Sometimes the better choice might be to lose the business and keep the home.
Require the Lender to Hold Off
The third issue is that a forbearance agreement needs to actually require the lender to hold off while the agreement lasts. General language on the bank’s right to call the agreement at any time lets it unilaterally shut down the debtor’s time to restructure.
Loans and forbearance agreements that give the lender a right to declare default on the borrower because its “financial condition” has changed for the worse almost always make the borrower’s job harder. A ”material adverse change” in the borrower’s financial condition should be taken out if possible, or carefully defined if not.
The original loan documents will usually remain in force during a forbearance period. Many loan agreements include language saying a borrower is in default whenever the lender ”feels insecure” in its belief that the loan will be repaid. It’s vague, and that’s dangerous, because it gives the bank too much room to maneuver. The worst possible outcome for a borrower and its officers and guarantors can come when loan document rights are waived, collateral is pledged or cash advanced, and then the lender walks away anyway, declaring a default.
A forbearance agreement can be the right choice, but whoever agrees to it must first understand every detail, know what they are giving up, and what new exposure they’re taking. Negotiate the forbearance on terms that protect your business, your assets, and the value you’ve worked to create. Banks are in the business of business. They have a keen eye on their interests, not yours. It is important to be aware of the power and ability of a bank or lender, no matter what you hear from the other side’s loan officer or other agent.