A merchant cash advance is not the same thing as a loan from a bank. Funders agree to give the business a lump sum of money and in exchange, the funder puts a lien on or buys outright a portion of the business’s accounts receivable and/or card sales (this is both credit and debit.) The reason most business owners chose to go this route is because their cash flow was slowing down and they needed access to money fast in order to continue operating.
Cash flow problems account for some 82% of small business failures, according to a U.S. Bank study, so you can imagine how attractive a merchant cash advance might seem if your business is experiencing cash flow issues and you need money to keep working. The MCA is quick and approval rates are high. However, for some, the factor rate and aggressive repayment schedule can create more problems than they solve.
For a business owner whose credit is weak or cash flow needs are dire, an MCA can be helpful. Getting approved is estimated to be as much as 84% through a funding service, compared to approval rates of 68% at a big bank and 65% with the Small Business Administration (SBA). Funding may arrive in one to two days. To a business on the ropes, it looks like an easy call.
Risky and Expensive
Merchant cash advances are risky and expensive, and not for everyone. Origination fees, funding fees, admin fees, and other fees can add up fast. The cost isn’t really interest, it’s a factor rate, which typically runs from 1.1 to 1.5 times the money that’s advanced. MCAs are often repaid by automatic daily or weekly debits from your bank account over short terms.
Defaulting can be really bad, so you need to be very careful to avoid this at all costs. Funders sometimes add default fees and penalties, and this can easily balloon the balance out to the moon. Your business and you personally, as the business owner, often have to sign a confession of judgment, so the funder can immediately obtain a judgment on you after default.
The Bankruptcy Case
Now, even bankruptcy doesn’t make the legal problems posed by the MCA go away, necessarily. The legal issues really turn on whether the MCA is treated as a loan or a true sale. The debtor will say it’s a secured loan, and typically, the creditor will argue that it’s a true sale of the receivables.
If it is treated as a loan, the funder might have a claim secured by the receivables, but the business can still use the receivables during reorganization. The claim will have to compete with the claims and priorities of other secured creditors, and can still be crammed down. The funder will be subject to the automatic stay and other Bankruptcy Code rules, too. All in all, this is probably the better scenario for the business.
On the flip side, if the court deems it to be a true sale, the receivables may not be part of the business’ bankruptcy estate, and they cannot be used to reorganize. Also, the funder may be able to collect them after the bankruptcy is filed, despite the automatic stay. Further, the funder may never even get dragged into the bankruptcy case at all. In other words, this is the worst case scenario for the business.
To decide, judges look at the language of the transaction documents and the creditor’s rights and remedies on default. They also look at how the two sides interacted with each other over the life of the relationship. So what you sign could affect whether the court thinks it’s a sale or a loan.
Can Make Sense for Some Businesses
An MCA can make sense for some businesses. For others, it’s a terrible way to raise funds. It’s important to understand the benefits and drawbacks before taking on one.