Don’t let anyone tell you that business debt can be wished away, it’s a fantasy, and it’s dangerous. Deal with it: it’s time to get yourself back in the driver’s seat, not back to wishing it away. Business debt can get manageable.
Two options help you manage business debt: restructuring (working with your creditors) and consolidation, you may have a sense of the former. Some owners and CEOs out there have heard about “restructure” and “consolidate” but think they are one and the same. They’re not, so here’s a quick guide to make sure you pick the right one to help your business.
Each business has it’s own unique situation, so I’m not saying one is better than the other, but you’re going to have to look really hard at your own circumstances before making any choice. I’d always lean on a trusted financial advisor, the CFO you already have, or an outside CFO consultant.
First: I define both, then: I compare and help you decide.
Debt Restructuring
What happens during the restructuring of debt is that you and the creditor figure out what percentage of the amount you owe you are going to pay back. That percentage can be 60% of what you owe, for example. The old contract is modified to excuse the other 40%. No new contract. In a word, settlement. And it only works if you can pay it (i.e., afford it) and the creditor agrees to forgive enough.
Debt restructuring is essentially a last-ditch attempt at avoiding failure. If you are a business or CEO considering restructuring, you’re likely having some difficulty, and the creditor knows it. Why creditors say yes: Getting something is likely better than if your company goes under; Plus, if it works, they may not have to go through the cost and pain of bankruptcy later.
Debt Consolidation Is a Sort of Refinancing
Consolidating is the non-bleak-equals-barely-hanging-on road. It’s a sort of refinancing, for situations that aren’t quite so dire. It’s when a group of smaller loans are combined into one.
How’s it work? Consolidating means the smaller high interest loans become one loan, with a lower rate. The cash you were spending on interest payments can now be devoted to principal. Now you can pay less each month, or more toward paying it off faster, depending on your cash flow, and priorities.
Consolidation means a new contract and new terms. It means the same paperwork, the same tax returns, financial statements, sales projections as the original borrowing. You can get one from banks, credit unions, the SBA and other government agencies and programs, and alternative lenders. Your goal should be to obtain better cash flow and a easier repayment schedule.
Which Should You Choose
Here we go, side by side. Restructuring is an old contract being altered, the creditor forgives part of the debt. Consolidation is a group of small loans being refinanced, for a better interest rate, when the situation is not that dire.
The two can look like they may do the same thing, and they do indeed have things in common, however, they are very different from one another, yet both can serve you when it comes to making your business debt easier to handle.
There’s no hard and fast rule. It depends. How much debt? What kind of debt? What industry is your company? How large? How much money coming in, and how much going out? I say that your CFO or accountant has to advise you on this, because they have the full financial picture and they can make sure to properly advise you. Get the whole story and your entire set of answers from your CFO, be it in house or outsourced.
The catch: not every lender will play ball with you, and you have to follow their rules. Even if you know which one you want, it may not be your choice. Lenders may refuse to restructure debt if the situation is not dire enough, and restructuring is usually not a great option anyway in other circumstances. Consolidation: If your business is new, the lender may not agree. If your credit is not good, the lender may say no. Or, even if your credit is good, you may want to consolidate but if you have too much debt, it might be more than the lender will let you borrow.
When you are in trouble, listen to the CFO lead you on how to handle the debt situation. If you don’t have a CFO, hire a fractional CFO (same thing as a CFO consultant). They can determine what is best for you when it comes to business debt: restructuring or consolidation.
Next steps: Know what you want, lower payments or faster payoff, or just keeping the doors open? Next, make a plan for the business, sit down with a CFO and call creditors. Restructuring, consolidation, both are band-aids to cover up the money woes. But if you’re losing money these band-aids won’t save you, and you’ll only delay failure. If you want to turnaround the business you have to set a long-term strategy to increase sales.