When the sales drop and you still don’t have quite enough to pay all your creditors, your first thought is that it’s easy. You have to pay the ones who will shut you down or not supply you again, and you just stall the ones who are the least likely to make your life a living hell. It makes sense. The kind of sense that comes out of being forced into a corner and having to make a rapid choice.
Think twice. First, if the business closes, can you personally owe anything? Besides tax agencies, think carefully about who you’ve guaranteed a payment to. Once you’ve gotten past that list of personal disaster, ask if you can lead through some very rough months.
Personally Liable for Some Taxes
An LLC or corporation isn’t a magic shield against all your personal liability. It comes as a shock, but you can be personally liable for some taxes even though you thought you had a company that stopped you from that. Tax agencies often end up coming late too, so they’re on your desk when other bills pile up and you just forget them till it’s really too late. As the owner you can owe, as can officers. Your bookkeeper needs to be careful, too, in case they get blamed for putting priority in all the wrong places.
Usually, personal liability comes down to sales taxes or use taxes and federal payroll taxes. The money you collected as sales tax wasn’t yours. It’s like a trust. Yes, that’s right, the sales tax money you took on Monday and spent on Tuesday was always the state’s money, not yours. Some states will call nonpayment conversion or theft.
Payroll tax is the amount taken from the workers in the business and matched by the business. The crucial thing to remember about payroll tax is that the part taken from your employees is their money, and your failing to give it to the government is just wrong. Once again, like sales tax, you’re being entrusted with someone else’s cash to send to the agency. Tax agencies can add up an enormous amount of interest and penalties onto the debt you owe them. It’s not fair, but it is true. Even the interest on their penalties will get charged. If it goes on too long, the interest and penalties can be larger than the tax you owed.
Even if you feel like the tax agencies have forgotten, interest and penalties just keep on accumulating until someone gets a collector working on it again. You can submit partial payments to the IRS. It helps to make payroll tax payments with a note on them that they are for the employee side. The business’s part can often just turn into a corporate debt.
So you should get the sales and payroll taxes paid first, even if you know it’s coming to the end of the ride. It’s not just a matter of protecting yourself; it may protect other employees too.
Guaranteed Debts
Every personal guaranty is a solemn vow. Vendors will often ask the owner of a new business to sign as a personal guaranty. Bank loans almost always have the personal guaranty, and you might well even have signed over your home as collateral. Even if you close the business they can and will still collect that money you owe them. Like elephants, creditors never forget an old debt. It’s surprising how few people remember they signed that guaranty a year or five years before. It’s usually only when you’re knee deep in trouble that a sales rep waves that piece of paper and asks when the money will be in the bank.
Get out the papers. Your memory is fallible. You just might owe far more than you remember. If the odds are even money that you might make it or that this could be the end of the ride, you should be trying to reduce what can hurt you when you are most vulnerable. That means getting your guaranteed debts lower if at all possible. If you do end up having to close, talk to the people you owe. Sometimes offering to pay one of the creditors first in exchange for a release can work.
Ask Yourself if It Is Worth It
Think this over. Hard. Sitting down and looking at the whole situation needs to be done before too long. Even if you can survive as a company, ask yourself if it is worth it. Take a deep breath, and ask yourself if you can take the stress of getting things right again.
Stress clouds judgment. It’s a simple fact, and one that hits you right when you need clear thinking. Consider hiring an expert, such as an accountant or an attorney. Their objective viewpoint helps you get past some of the challenges that come up. Decide whether you think the cash problems can be fixed or whether you want to say enough is enough, and bring that professional expertise into the problem so you can do it with confidence.
Perhaps you’re profitable except for one horrible incident. Or maybe a catastrophe that wasn’t covered by insurance is a situation your business can’t handle. For some situations, Chapter 11 is a possible solution. While you’re in it, nobody can just take legal action to collect money from you. Sometimes, it may stop collection on your guaranties as well. Weigh the pros and cons very carefully, as this is not a solution to try alone. There are sharp lawyers waiting in this market, and you’ll need to find one with the wisdom of Solomon to guide you.
A surprising number of businesses wind up just closing, without bankruptcy, and selling what assets there are to pay the creditors. Lienholders are paid first, and everybody else divides what’s left after that. When you try to keep going long enough to give yourself a paycheck for as long as possible, you may be causing others to wait even longer to receive anything. If you see the end coming, then ask for help in time to do things right.