Although a judge signed off on a judgment in your favor, that doesn’t mean you necessarily get paid. How do you collect your small claims judgment from a business?
Written Demand Letter
After you’ve won your small claims case, send a written demand letter to the debtor. This letter states that the debtor must pay the amount owed, which you and the court have determined, and must do so within a specified period of time. If you haven’t heard back from the debtor after your initial letter, send another one once a month to continue your demand of payment. Include in the demand letters the interest that has accumulated on the judgment amount. Additionally, give the debtor a call or two and keep being a pest until the debtor gets rid of you by paying off their debt!
Other Avenues to Pursue
After you’ve tried repeatedly to demand the judgment payment and the debtor still refuses, there are other avenues to pursue. So what can you do?
You can record a lien on a business real estate property based on the judgment you’ve received from the court and they’ll have to pay it off when they sell the property. That will ding the company’s credit as well. The judgment lien can be foreclosed, but that’s really technical and costly. The bad part about foreclosing is that you may need to pay off any senior mortgages or liens on that property. In Colorado, get a transcript of the judgment from the clerk and record it at the county land records office.
If you know where the debtor banks, you may be able to garnish their account. There’s a form, and you might need to get it stamped by the clerk. Then, mail it in to the debtor company and the bank. There may be a local requirement for a process server to deliver the bank garnishment.
If you don’t know their bank, or any of their assets, post-judgment discovery might be your best bet. You can serve them with Rule 69 interrogatories or take the depositions of the company’s officers, to find out assets and income. It’s a little involved, with lots of forms, but sometimes it’s the only way. It can be annoying enough that it gets their attention. Of course, you could also just hire a private investigator to track the company down and locate any of their assets.
A writ of execution and attachment is another option. A writ of execution allows the sheriff to seize the company’s tangible personal property and store it, and then auction it off. There are lots of filings and fees, but you’ll need to work with the sheriff’s civil division. What else do you need? You’re on the hook for liability bonds the sheriff often demands, plus moving costs, storage costs, a notice in a legal newspaper about the sale, and a locksmith, and maybe even an appraiser to value everything. It’s expensive, and a headache to manage.
You can garnish money that other customers or businesses owe to the company. You fill out the paperwork, like with a bank garnishment. It can be bumpier, and more likely to be litigated, because businesses aren’t as used to dealing with garnishments, as banks are.
If you’ve completed post judgment discovery on the company and you discover that assets have been given away while the company was insolvent without fair value, you can sue the recipients separately under the fraudulent transfers act. It’s nearly impossible to do without a lawyer.
If nothing else is working, you can sue the company to have it dissolved, and its assets liquidated, because it’s not paying its debts. You probably don’t want to do this over a small claims judgment. You’ll need a lawyer for this one.
You can team up with other unpaid creditors to force the company into involuntary bankruptcy. This, though, is nearly impossible without a lawyer.
Alternatively, if you think the company may be about to declare bankruptcy, wait for it to happen, then simply file a one- or two-page claim form with the bankruptcy court.
But fair warning: many of these tools require a ton of complicated paperwork and procedures, and it’s challenging for a regular person, without advanced education or business experience, to make sure they get it right. Plus, fees add up.
Another idea is publicity. Let other people know about the company’s failure to pay on a court judgment.
Another trick is to find the company’s landlord and biggest lenders. An unpaid court judgment is often a default under many leases and large loans, and a problem that needs to be cured as soon as possible.
For publicity, post about the nonpayment on customer review sites and social media. Sometimes it works, sometimes it won’t.
Paying a Lawyer or a Collection Agency
Finally, hire someone else to collect the judgment. You could hire a lawyer. You could hire a collection agency. They’re often happier to chase an actual judgment than an unproven claim.
Even if you went pro se to small claims court, it might be worth paying someone to collect your judgment. And referring it to a collections agency hurts the company’s credit too.
Will a lawyer take your case on a contingency? You’ll likely have to pay a fee of about one-third to one-half of your recovery. But you might be able to pay a lawyer an hourly fee, $150 to $450 per hour in Nevada, and it will take a minimum of several hours for the lawyer to do it.
Of course, if the judgment’s tiny, the hourly attorney fee may outweigh the whole judgment, and the collections agency may turn you down if the amount they recover is too small to be worth the work.
In the end, it’s a giant hassle to chase a small claims judgment, especially one that’s tiny.