When your business can’t meet all of its financial obligations, who do you pay? You pay the bills that must be paid and skip those that can wait.
Banks and other lenders, vendors who supply inventory or services, and employees all like to be paid when they’re owed money. But if your business has cash flow problems, there are two groups of entities that will move to the front of the creditor line. Those two groups are taxing agencies, federal, state, or local governments, and loan guaranty holders.
Personally Liable for Payroll Taxes
Don’t assume that incorporating or forming a limited liability company (LLC) will isolate you from tax problems. In certain cases, it may not. It can take a while for a taxing agency such as the IRS or the state Department of Revenue to get around to you. So, you think, why should you pay the IRS when a vendor wants its money, right now? But owners, officers and even a bookkeeper who makes decisions about which bills get paid can be personally liable for payroll taxes.
As a small-business owner, keep in mind that two kinds of tax liabilities may affect you: Trust fund or withholding taxes and sales and use taxes. When your business collects sales tax from a customer, it is money you hold in trust for the state or other tax-collection agency. In the tax collector’s eyes, you never actually had that money. Some states call spending it conversion or stealing.
Federal payroll taxes involve the payroll tax you take from the employee and match with the employer’s part. The deduction from the employee’s wages was never your property. The deduction is the employee’s. You can get hit with a steep penalty and interest for failure to pay payroll taxes or sales taxes. Perhaps even scarier than the penalties are the interest on the penalties that can accrue, and the total can soon exceed the original tax.
Just because you don’t hear from the IRS, doesn’t mean the penalties aren’t running. If you are struggling to pay creditors, and you have to decide what to pay, the best approach is to direct any partial payment to the trust fund part of the payroll tax. If a tax bill has to wait, let it be the employer share of payroll taxes. Ordinarily, the law looks at the employer’s share of payroll tax and the trust fund withholding separately. The employer’s share is simply a business debt. Therefore, the company is merely late in paying this liability.
First among the taxes to pay right away, regardless of whether your company survives or eventually dissolves, are payroll and sales taxes.
Personal Guaranties
When you started your business, chances are you set up shop with borrowed money. To get that loan, you almost certainly signed a personal guaranty for the debt, meaning that if the business can’t make the payment, you’ve put yourself on the hook. Depending on the business, personal guaranties to suppliers may be widespread and pervasive. Many entrepreneurs have had to give a personal guaranty on a small-business loan, but after a few years of making regular payments, forgot about it. Like elephants, creditors never forget. They may not make a lot of noise while you’re trying to get things together, but they’re not going away.
So, now is not the time to take chances with trusting your memory. Check all of your business loan documents to see if any of them included personal guaranties on business loans. If your business’s odds of surviving are even or low, and you have guarantied loans, pay them first. If you decide you can’t make it and will have to close the business, try to negotiate a release on your personal guaranties, at least on any remaining guaranties, from the creditors. Find out how much they’re willing to take in satisfaction of their debt.
Evaluate Your Company’s Chances of Surviving
Can the business really survive?
It’s wise to evaluate your company’s chances of surviving rather than go on just hoping it will. Is the stress level too high? When business difficulties cause you to lose your health or ruin your life, then maybe it’s time to quit while you’re ahead.
Decision making is harder for some people under stress, and too much anxiety and worry have been known to push a person to make a wrong choice. It’s a good idea to surround yourself with advisors who can share your burden and bring their expertise to your decision-making process. A good insolvency professional will help you figure out if you can survive or what will happen to you if you have to close.
If bankruptcy can help you survive, the best choice may be Chapter 11, designed for businesses that need to continue operating. It may help when a core business is viable but there is a reason outside the ordinary (and uninsured) that the company can’t pay its bills. Normally when you file bankruptcy, the filing automatically prevents creditors from trying to collect what they’re owed, sometimes including from you as guarantor. Chapter 11 is expensive and time-consuming, and so complex that it is crucial to talk over options with a competent attorney.
When you decide not to go the bankruptcy route and want to dissolve your company, there will come a time when you will vote to authorize the business to cease operating and to liquidate its assets. First paid are secured creditors, such as banks that lent you money and took collateral in the form of liens on business assets. If there is any money left after that, it goes to unsecured creditors that had no collateral. A common error is to stay in business to continue drawing a salary. You shouldn’t keep the business open just to feed yourself, and you shouldn’t keep it open to pay yourself more than you can pay others. If you get even a whiff of serious problems affecting your ability to repay, talk to your trusted professional advisors.