Getting financing is one of the biggest hurdles when starting or growing a business. It can be challenging to secure a loan from a financial institution, especially if you’re a first-time borrower. You may be asked to provide a personal guaranty if the business you’re starting or running has limited assets. A lender will do everything it can to collect on the guaranty. However, there are a few cases where the guaranty may not be enforceable.
A guaranty is a promise to repay the debt of another person or entity. The guarantor agrees to become liable for the debt of another person or company in the event they default on their loan payments. When a student borrows from a lender, they may be asked to secure a co-signer to agree to pay the loan balance if the student is unable to do so. The parent co-signs the loan and becomes liable for repayment of the debt if the student is unable to pay. A personal guarantee on a business is when the owner, or owners, sign a guarantee for the loan.
A personal guaranty on a loan means that you, personally, are liable for repayment. If the business defaults on the loan, you will then be liable to pay.
A Simple Example
Let’s look at how this works with a simple example.
Your company makes widgets. You need to increase production, which means investing in more machinery and inventory.
So you borrow money from a bank for the purchase of additional equipment. The equipment you purchase serves as collateral, and the bank has a security interest in the equipment. What the bank also asks is for your personal guaranty.
Now, let’s say that the company can’t pay the loan.
To recoup its losses, the bank files a lawsuit against your company for non-payment. The lawsuit also names you individually, because you gave a personal guaranty.
Based on the terms of the contract, you would become personally liable to pay whatever balance that the value of the equipment doesn’t cover.
Anything that you have is on the line if you give a personal guaranty on the loan. The bank may seek your home, bank accounts, savings, investments or even garnish your wages.
There are some insurance products that may offer coverage for guaranties. Ask your insurance agent.
Your Personal Guaranty May Not Hold Up
A personal guaranty may seem like a necessary evil in getting your business off the ground. It’s in your best interest to know what you are signing. Even big banks can make a mistake on your loan. There are instances where your personal guaranty may not hold up, or be enforceable.
In Ohio, under R.C. 1335.05, a personal guaranty must be in writing. If the guaranty was never reduced to writing, you may not be liable. When you get a demand for payment, be sure to ask for a copy of the contract in which the guaranty was provided. It falls to the lender to prove that your guaranty exists. They have to be able to produce the written contract that contains the guaranty.
The guaranty must be executed personally, as an individual. For example, if the guaranty you signed on behalf of your company was signed as “James Jones, President”, it may not be enforceable. Your company is an entity, separate from you as an individual. If the guaranty is written only on behalf of the business, the lender may not be able to make a claim against you individually.
A guaranty is a contract. All contracts require something called “consideration”. Consideration is the exchange of something of value. There must be some consideration provided in exchange for the guaranty. On a business loan, the consideration for the guaranty is the loan itself.
Also, when the lender sues you, they have to be able to prove that the debt is owed. Records can get destroyed or lost in the transferring of loans from one lender to the next. It’s possible the guaranty you signed wasn’t transferred over.
Ways to Get Out of It
Once a guaranty is given, the lender may have the right to hold the debt over your head for some time to come. Still, there are ways to get out of it. You can revoke your guaranty any time the two parties agree, in writing. If you declare bankruptcy, some of your debts as guarantor may be discharged.
Each situation is unique and must be evaluated individually.