For most small business owners, getting financing is one of the hardest things to do. Credit standards for small businesses are very strict and many business loans require a personal guaranty from the owners of the business. If the loan defaults, the lender can come after the owner of the business, not just the business assets. But how much should an owner be willing to pledge in order to guaranty the debt and what are some ways to limit potential losses if the business fails?
Repay the Debts of Another Person
A personal guaranty is a promise that is made by one person to repay the debts of another person. The guarantor is the individual who pledges to pay on the debt. The guarantor can be the borrower (such as an owner of the business) or an outside person, a third party.
If you as the business owner guaranty a business loan, you are legally committing yourself to paying the debt if the business can’t make the payments. If the assets of your business fall short, the lender will try to collect the rest of what is owed from you. If you can’t pay, then your home, your checking account, your savings and investments, and even your future wages all may be at risk.
In most cases, the lender can go after you as guarantor right away, regardless of whether the business has the cash to pay. Most commercial guaranties are guaranties of payment and not guaranties of collection. This means the guarantor promises to pay what is owed immediately, regardless of whether the lender sues the borrower’s business. Also, when there’s a guaranty, lenders often sue both the business and the guarantor at the same time, although they could just go against you individually without suing the business.
Limited recourse loans have the same basic features as the full recourse loans described above. However, with limited recourse loans the lender agrees to cap what it can recover from the guarantor, either as a fixed dollar amount or a percentage of the loan.
Generally, if there’s a non-recourse loan, the guarantor is not personally liable for the loan except when certain “carve-outs” apply. The term ”carve-outs” refers to situations where non-recourse loan provisions don’t apply. A partial list of carve-outs includes fraud, waste, misrepresentation, bankruptcy, and environmental contamination. If the borrower hands the property over to the lender and there was no carve-out breach, the guarantor has no further obligation. If a carveout was breached, then you may be on the hook.
Limit Your Personal Liability
For many small businesses, guarantying a loan is often necessary. However, there are a few strategies you should use to avoid some of the pitfalls when you’re guarantying a loan. One of the toughest situations is when minority owners guaranty the loans for their companies. This can lead to a serious problem if the company becomes unable to repay the loan. Minority owners generally have little say in how the company’s money is spent or whether the loan is repaid.
A minority owner should not overlook this possibility. Don’t rely on trust. Instead, get a written agreement that the company will pay any loan that you’ve guaranteed before it pays anything else, including payments to other owners. This agreement should also include a provision that the company will indemnify you, that is, the company will reimburse you for any amounts that you may have to pay on the loan.
If you’re not the only person who’s guarantying the loan, you should try to get an agreement with the other guarantors to share the losses if the loan isn’t paid. Each guarantor of the loan can be held responsible for the entire amount of the debt. This means that a creditor doesn’t have to go after each guarantor for only a specific part of the debt. However, the law on contribution between guarantors is murky and varies from state to state. So put that agreement on how the losses will be shared in writing. But be aware: there can be federal income tax consequences from sharing the debt.
When the borrower is a partnership, or an LLC that’s taxed as a partnership, the loss allocations can create some pretty complicated tax results.
You may be able to limit your personal liability by guaranteeing only a part of the loan instead of the whole thing. As the guarantor, you’re responsible only for the amount of the loan that you’ve guaranteed. Those who guarantee only a part are known as ”partial guarantors”; guarantors that owe the full amount are called ”full guarantors”.
Another option is a guaranty of collection, which means the guarantor pays only after the lender wins a judgment against the borrower and execution comes back unsatisfied. Here, you can add a condition that all collateral that secures the loan be sold and that the proceeds of the sale be applied first to the debt.
A guaranty can be cancelled after it’s made. The guarantor and lender can agree in writing to revoke the guaranty. In some cases, guaranties are drafted so they will automatically expire after a fixed amount of time or only apply up to a certain dollar cap. Finally, filing for bankruptcy can sometimes eliminate some of the guarantor’s debt.
Whether a guaranty can be enforced depends on a variety of legal issues and the particular circumstances in each case.